Was haig a butcher or war

At the outbreak of the first world war, in august 1914, douglas haig served as a deputy to john french who had become commander-in-chief of the british expeditionary force. Mr kosta's classroom the victors of world war i after all and haig certainly can sir douglas haig be considered either a butcher or a hero of the. General haig was the general that led the attacks in the battle of somme after the war, he was bitterly criticized for underestimating the germans and people gave him the name butcher of somme. If haig deserves credit for winning the war as con claims, despite the contributions of his other officers, then surely he also deserves credit for the butchery of the somme despite the contributions of his other officers. Douglas haig © haig was british commander on the western front for most of world war one the huge casualties that his military strategy produced has made him a controversial figure douglas haig was born. Was haig the butcher of the some may say haig’s intentions were simply focused on winning the war haig took command at a time when the british army was.

Douglas haig – butcher or hero by rupert colley next almost a decade after the war, haig still believed in the use of cavalry: butcher haig haig has. Therefore he has been viewed as both 'butcher of the somme at the end of the war the relationship between douglas haig and david lloyd george was a cause. Haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, and he had had a very successful military career haig decided to attack the germans at the river somme in 1916 to attract german soldiers from the town of verdun where they were fighting the french and had almost broken through. Field marshal douglas haig, seen here visiting troops circa 1916, has long been disparaged as the 'butcher of the somme' for deaths during the first world war he is the aloof scotsman with a reputation as cold as his bronze statue at the cenotaph in london.

Does haig deserve his nickname the butcher of the somme feild marshall haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career haig decided to attack the germans at the river somme in 1916 to attract german. Was haig the butcher of the somme topic: history how can you rely on haig’s suggestions and views on the war, when he wasn’t even on the front line. However, it was no secret that a war was waged between haig and lloyd george an example of the tension between these characters was on the 1st september, when haig received a telegram from henry wilson, marked 'personal', this carried a warning, that haig was to stop preventable casualties during the battle of the somme. Was general haig a hero, butcher or bungler was general haig a hero in the first world war haig tried and failed again and again the same idea with men against.

Essay - field marshal sir douglas haig: war hero or butcher of the somme many historians see the somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of the war the devastating casualties and deaths of the war left thousands without their loved ones, a whole generation was lost at the somme. Field marshal haig: “hero or butcher of the somme” i consider the field marshal as a butcher and a hero for numerous reasons while the insinuation of haig as a butcher ignores many positives that he possessed, the implication of him being a hero also neglects negatives that the field marshal obtains. Open document below is an essay on was general haig a butcher of the somme from anti essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples.

Was haig a butcher or war

Interpretation that haig was a butcher: source b2 was written by p - interpretation that haig was/wasn't a butcher (source analysis) introduction smith a private in the 1st border regiment during the somme describes the. Was general haig a butcher catsareyumyum loading the great war 169,076 views 9:09 was haig the butcher of the somme - duration: 3:54.

  • Talk:douglas haig , 1st earl haig this haig has since the 1960s become an object of criticism for his leadership during the first world war some called him.
  • Due to this, douglas haig earned the reputation as 'butcher of the somme' but was this a fair title given to a man who was judged by the 21st century defence: 'douglas haig was a brave and intelligent man, for he was educated at oxford university and later attended sand hurst military school.
  • Was general haig the 'butcher of the somme' (no rating) 0 the leadership of the british army during the war is traditionally described by some historians as.
  • Did wwi’s ‘butcher of the somme’ get an unfair rep but does haig deserve the burden of the butcher in the final years leading up to the great war, haig.
  • Field marshal douglas haig, 1st earl haig, kt, gcb, om, gcvo, kcie (/heɪɡ/ 19 june 1861 – 29 january 1928) was a senior officer of the british army during the first world war he commanded the british expeditionary force (bef) on the western front from late 1915 until the end of the war.

For instance, after the war haig was often criticised for issuing orders, which led to excessive casualties of british troops under his command, particularly on the western front this earned him the nickname butcher of the somme haig's critics included many younger officers who served in the first world war. Haig's reputation as the butcher of the somme essay 654 words | 3 pages haig's reputation as the butcher of the somme in the run up to the war, field marshal sir douglas haig was appointed the director of military training. Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme - part 2 - british army essay example 1 july 1916, battle of somme started, fought by the armies of the british and french empires against the german empire - did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme introduction. Did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme in june 1914 a serb assassinated franz ferdinand, the heir to the throne of the austrian empire austria decided to take revenge against serbia and invaded. Douglas haig, britain’s first world war commander-in-chief from december 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal ‘donkey butcher haig. General haig a butcher not war hero - sir douglas haig was born on the 19th june 1861 the field marshal was very highly ranked in the duration of the great war haig was a british soldier and a senior commander of the british expeditionary force from.

was haig a butcher or war Does general haig deserve the title the butcher of the somme - assignment example on in assignment sample the battle of the somme was one of the most significant events in british war history. was haig a butcher or war Does general haig deserve the title the butcher of the somme - assignment example on in assignment sample the battle of the somme was one of the most significant events in british war history.
Was haig a butcher or war
Rated 5/5 based on 12 review